Too often, I have met people who consider concern for nature to be something for children, old people and wimps. Serious contenders, they say, know that money makes the world go around and the market must be fed. The ability to make money from something, they say, overrules any and all other considerations for it.
We too often exemplify that attitude to our children, even when we do not want to do so. We talk about healthy foods, but buy them sweets and sodas "for a treat", thus teaching them that our talk about health has no meaning, if we make a "treat" of what is bad for them. We risk communicating to them at the least that we are weak, at the most that, because we give them what we know to be bad for them, we do not care for them. In the same way, we talk about the need to reduce global warming, stop pollution and the destruction of forests yet, has anyone given up their car? Has anyone accepted that we will have to do with less? We will not be able to replace all of our polluting products with green alternatives. We will have to do without. We will have to change. A large part of the world's population is descended from people who emigrated to new and unknown lands. They were capable of enormous change, so we know it is possible for us to change when necessary. There is an expression that says if you want to know the truth about a person, you must "look at what a person does, not at what he or she says." Our children copy our actions, not our words.
As they observe us cutting trees, burning forests, logging woods, brutalizing and killing animals, spraying fields, dumping our filth into the water we and all species need to drink, ripping up land with mining, all for the sake of the market, they learn that money is the only thing we care about. We teach greed and selfishness and a certain disgusting kind of slothfulness. Do we really want our children to inherit such characteristics? The resulting generation will be a greater thing to fear than a planet that has lost its last shred of green to concrete.
I have often heard the argument against the protection of nature as that God gave Adam "the dominion over....every creeping thing that creeps on the earth." I believe that right would have been lost on the expulsion from Eden, but I will not discuss theology here. I will discuss dominion, or ruling, however. What kind of ruler slaughters all of his or her subjects? Nero, Stalin, Hitler, etc. Are they the definitive representatives of our god-given behaviour? Of our species?
A respect and a consideration for other species should come from more than our desire for survival, more than our desire to have beautiful places to visit and animals to observe. It should come from our desire to be better human beings. For some people, the market and its cruelties takes priority over all other needs, but most people feel that there is a limit, a barrier they will not cross. For most people, there are things that we will not do, no matter how much money we might get if we did. Those people have a sense of right and wrong, a sense of decency, and courage, and those are senses that we want to instill in our children. They will be better people for it and there will be a better future for us all.
William Blake put it most clearly:
A Robin Redbreast in a Cage
A robin redbreast in a cage
Puts all heaven in a rage;
A dog starved at his master's gate
Predicts a ruin of the State;
A game-cock clipped and armed for fight
Doth the rising sun affright;
A horse misused upon the road
Calls to heaven for human blood;
Each outcry of the hunted hare
A fiber from the brain doth tear;
A skylark wounded on the wing
Doth make a cherub cease to sing;
He who shall hurt the little wren
Shall never be belovèd by men;
The beggar's dog and widow's cat,
Feed them and thou shalt grow fat.
Discuss the meaning of this poem with children.
Go over it with them and explain that the poet is saying that a person who can inflict cruelty on an animal has cruelty as a part of his or her character. A person who is indifferent to suffering is selfish. Selfish and cruel people are not the society we want, for their selfishness and cruelty will extend to all aspects of their lives. And we don't want that.
©2009 Anne Morddel
Seasons South and North
Technorati Profile